Comment from: Rich [Visitor]
RichThat competitiverunner article is huge sack of fail. Asking people whose salaries come from the shoe companies whether running barefoot would be beneficial is like asking plaintiff's side med mal lawyers whether medical tort reform is a good thing.

Beyond that, there are countless possible explanations for why reasons elite runners don't (yet?) run barefoot or in VFFs. First, I think the reason many of use came to "minimal running" is that we were tired of being injured in regular shoes. The runners quoted in the article are not hurt and haven't had the kinds of significant overuse injuries that plague many of us when wearing regular shoes.

Second and related, most elite runners have excellent running form regardless of what they run in. So to the extent people turn to barefoot/minimal running as a way to correct their form, there's no need for most elites.

Third, going barefoot means significantly scaling back your training while you adapt. Most elites can't afford to do that.

Fourth, if you're a highly competitive elite like Goucher, Geb, or Hall, you're probably not going to change what's been working for you unless there's damn good evidence it will give you an advantage (and as we all know, there are not yet studies on speed differences between barefoot and shod).

Fifth, just because they're good runners doesn't mean they understand the biomechanics or physics at play better than any intelligent person looking at the as-yet limited data.

Sixth, the article itself shows that many elites haven't even seriously considered barefoot because of their own biases/pre-cpnceptions. For example, Kara Goucher said she'd be "scared" to run without her arch supports. Ok, so if they work for her then great, but isn't she really saying that she doesn't know if barefoot would be faster, she's just scared to try?

I could keep going, but I think you get the point. Basically, it boils down to this: there's no data showing that either barefoot or shod is faster than the other, and getting anecdotal quotes from elite runners, or even looking at what elite runners do, doesn't solve the question because they're all starting from the assumption that shoes are best and the experience of doing well in shoes.

Oh, and did I mention that the shoe companies pay these people? ;)
05/10/10 @ 10:39